explore · Problem Solving · 45–75 min · 3-30 people · high energy

The Maker's Mystery Challenge

A hands-on creative challenge where participants must build a physical prototype or 'invention' using a limited set of random materials to solve a specific, often absurd, prompt.

When to use The Maker's Mystery Challenge

To stimulate lateral thinking and demonstrate how constraints can actually drive innovation.

What it solves

Analysis paralysis or a team that is stuck in conventional ways of thinking.

How to run The Maker's Mystery Challenge, step by step

  1. Participants open their 'Mystery Boxes' simultaneously on camera (5 minutes).
  2. Facilitator reveals the challenge prompt, e.g., 'Build a device for an alien to eat soup' (2 minutes).
  3. Individual or small group 'Build Phase' where participants construct their items (20 minutes).
  4. 'The Pitch'—each person has 60 seconds to sell their invention to the group (15 minutes).
  5. Use a digital poll to vote on 'Most Innovative' or 'Best Storytelling' (5 minutes).

Materials needed

  • Pre-mailed boxes with items like pipe cleaners, foil, rubber bands, etc.
  • Timer
  • Polling tool

Facilitator tips

  • Play upbeat, 'tinkering' music during the build phase.
  • Encourage participants to use 'storytelling' rather than just describing the object.

Common pitfalls

  • Participants over-thinking the 'engineering' rather than the 'creativity'.
  • Uneven kits leading to feelings of unfairness.

Variations

  • Digital version using only items found within 5 feet of the participant's desk.

Running it online or hybrid

Ensure remote participants receive their physical kits at least 48 hours in advance. In-person participants should have identical kits.

What it produces

Physical prototypes and a series of 'pitches' for the new inventions.

Origin

Based on teambuilding.com's 'Online Mystery Box Challenge' — source

Build a session around The Maker's Mystery Challenge

METODIC places The Maker's Mystery Challenge inside a complete, timed session plan — agenda, worksheets, facilitator guide and slides — matched to your group and goal.

Generate a session with The Maker's Mystery Challenge · Try METODIC free